Skip to content

What Happens When Technical Systems Fail?

19. oktober, 2026

Pumps, oxygenation and water treatment are essential to stable operations. Even minor deviations can have significant biological and financial consequences.

A pump stops at an aquaculture facility.

The water flow changes. Other parts of the process may be affected. Meanwhile, the fish still depend on stable environmental conditions.

What happens next?

Does the backup pump start automatically? Does the operator receive the right alarm? And can the remaining systems maintain safe conditions while the fault is being addressed?

This is a hypothetical scenario, but the questions are very real.

In modern aquaculture, water quality, oxygen supply and water treatment are closely connected to technical systems. When one critical function fails, the consequences can spread throughout the facility.

In the worst case, fish welfare and production may be affected. The financial consequences can far exceed the cost of the component that failed.

”In aquaculture, the consequences do not necessarily end with the technical failure. Behind these systems are living fish that depend on the process working as intended. That is why we need to understand what happens throughout the facility when one critical function fails,” says Aleksander Mork-Knudsen, Head of the Aquaculture Division at Guard Automation.

One Failure Can Trigger Another

A pump stopping is not necessarily an isolated event. Reduced water flow can affect other functions, and the consequences depend on factors such as production load and the backup systems available.

No complex technical facility can be designed on the assumption that every component will always operate without failure.

Power supplies can fail. Communication can be lost. A sensor can report an incorrect value while continuing to transmit signals to the control system.

The critical question is therefore not simply what went wrong, but what the failure means for the rest of the facility.

Which functions must remain operational? Which backup equipment should start? What should the system handle automatically? And when does the operator need to intervene?

These questions are also reflected in regulatory requirements. Aquaculture facilities that depend on electrical power or oxygen supply are subject to requirements for backup or emergency solutions and alarm systems. Closed production units are also required to provide warnings of system failures that may affect fish welfare or increase the risk of escape.

It is not only about detecting that something has gone wrong. The facility must be prepared to limit the consequences.

Two Pumps Are Not Always Enough

Redundancy is an important principle for protecting critical functions. But having an additional component does not necessarily provide the level of security expected.

If the main pump and backup pump depend on the same power supply or control system, a single common failure can still affect both.

Resilience therefore involves more than the number of components. It requires an understanding of the entire chain of dependencies — from power supply and field equipment to communication, automation, alarm management and the operator.

Through its research and development activities, FHF has highlighted risks associated with technical and operational conditions in recirculating aquaculture systems (RAS). Monitoring, alarms, redundancy and effective deviation management are relevant measures for reducing vulnerability.

”Redundancy is not simply about having two of something. We also need to understand which dependencies the solutions share. Only when we consider the entire system can we assess how resilient the facility really is when something fails,” says Mork-Knudsen.

What If the System Does Not Detect the Failure?

Not every technical failure causes something to stop.

A sensor may continue to provide measurements, but those measurements may be incorrect. If automated functions are controlled based on this information, what appears to be a minor fault can have consequences for the process.

This places demands on sensor quality, the control system and the operator's ability to identify deviations.

Having more measurement points does not necessarily provide better control if they are vulnerable to the same source of error.

The question is therefore not only how much data the facility collects, but whether that information can be trusted when decisions need to be made.

And when the system does raise an alarm, another question emerges: Does the operator receive the information needed to act?

When the Alarm Sounds, the Real Test Begins

A technical incident can trigger multiple alarms within a short period.

In that situation, the operator does not necessarily need more information. The operator needs the right information.

What happened first? Which functions have been affected? What actions has the system already taken automatically? And which measures require immediate attention?

Effective alarm management is therefore about more than issuing warnings. It should help make the situation understandable and manageable.

Guard Automation has worked with several of these challenges as the automation partner for Ovum in the development of its closed aquaculture concept, Egget.

The facility uses a large number of signals to monitor operations and track parameters including water quality, oxygen and temperature. Critical functions such as oxygen dosing, emergency power, pumps and circuit breakers are also monitored.

The automation system supports functions including oxygen level regulation, pump control and controlled emergency operation.

This example illustrates an important principle: Automation should not only support efficient operations when everything works as planned. It should also support operators when something unexpected happens.

”It is often only when a deviation occurs that we see how well the different systems actually work together. The goal is for the operator to understand the situation quickly, while critical functions are managed in a controlled manner,” says Mork-Knudsen.

When Technology Fails, Fish Welfare Is at Stake

When a critical alarm is triggered, many of the conditions determining what happens next have already been established.

They are embedded in how the facility was designed, which dependencies were identified, how backup functions were configured and how the control system responds to deviations.

For the fish, it makes little difference whether the failure originates in a pump, a sensor or a control system. What matters is whether their environmental conditions remain safe.

An incident that is detected and managed quickly and effectively may have limited consequences. An incident that goes undetected or is not addressed in time, however, can affect fish welfare and production, with financial consequences for the fish farmer.

Guard Automation has spent decades working with automation and control systems for critical infrastructure. This industrial systems expertise is equally relevant in aquaculture, where technical functions are closely connected to biological needs.

Because technical failures and deviations will occur.

What matters is how well the facility is prepared when they do.

What Happens When Technical Systems Fail? | Guard Automation